« 91% of Lawyers Unhappy Law School Did Not Teach Them About Marketing | Main | A Divergence: The W-List - Introducing You to Outstanding Women Bloggers »

August 08, 2007

Bankruptcy - The New Blue Chip Practice Area?

(UPDATE:  I teased Attorney Maseles out with this post and he added a very valuable comment regarding going into creditor's work.  Please check it out.)

Earlier this year I wrote several posts on why solos should get involved with bankruptcy.  I also had Richard Maseles, Associate General Counsel of the Missouri Department of Revenue, guest post on this site as to why it is a good area for solos and small firms to build bankruptcy practice due to questionable economic times ominously foreshadowed.

Today, a well regarded newsletter I subscribe to provided the following e-mail update discussing an article in the New York Times featuring Richard Levin, a highly regarded bankruptcy lawyer, who has left Skadden to go to Cravath.  I personally am uninterested in his change of law firms from a gossipy perspective.  The article is most interesting to me from an economic perspective and how it impacts practice area choices for new and existing solos.  Would love to know your thoughts.

Everyone Is Preparing  (Oustanding Investments, Byron King.)

“Everyone, it seems, is preparing for a coming wave of new bankruptcy filings,” noted a recent aritcle in The New York Times   

According to Robert Sheehan, the managing partner of the law firm of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom, there is a tsunami coming in the bankruptcy arena. Mr. Sheehan made his comment before the recent stock market gyrations of the past couple of weeks, but he was merely looking ahead to what he, apparently, views, in his legal opinion, as the inevitable outcome of what has been going on in the U.S. economy these past several years.

The New York Times article to which I am referring profiled an attorney named Richard Levin, who practices primarily in the field of bankruptcy law. Among his other accomplishments, Mr. Levin served from 1975-1978 as counsel to the U.S. House Judiciary Committee, where he helped to draft much of the present U.S. Bankruptcy Code. Mr. Levin has had a distinguished career in the bankruptcy field and was recently hired away from his previous law firm, Skadden Arps, where he had been a partner for a decade, to join the old-line New York firm of Cravath, Swaine & Moore. This is symbolic, if not significant, for reasons we will discuss below.

The Ultimate Go-to Firm

In a profile published on July 25, 2007, the authoritative Dow Jones’ Daily Bankruptcy Review described Cravath as “the ultimate go-to firm,” and further noted that Cravath “has perhaps the most demanding hiring standards” of any New York law firm. So it says something loud and clear that Cravath is hiring the guy who literally “wrote the book” for modern bankruptcy practice in the U.S., to include drafting the 1978 amendments to the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. Combine this with the fact that Cravath previously had no significant bankruptcy practice in recent decades (actually, Cravath reorganized Westinghouse after the Panic of 1907 and assisted with many railway reorganizations over the past century), although many of its fine attorneys have appeared often in the bankruptcy courts of many federal and foreign venues and jurisdictions. But it is fair to say that Cravath was not known lately as a “bankruptcy firm” in any respect. Rather, Cravath focused much of its large-caliber legal effort on what is called “transactional” work, such as putting together large merger and acquisition deals, or dealing with matters before the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and similar foreign entities. The blue chip client list of the white-shoe Cravath law firm includes such powerhouse organizations as IBM, Xerox, Merck, Novartis, the board of directors of TXU, Credit Suisse and the Carlyle Group.

A Continental Shift

The New York Times article noted that “Cravath’s move, in the words of one bankruptcy lawyer in New York, was ‘a continental shift,’ a recognition by an old-line firm, however belatedly, that bankruptcy had moved beyond the days when it was the purview of collection lawyers chasing debtors to the courthouse.” Having practiced a good deal of bankruptcy law in my misspent youth, I take exception to that last characterization. Bankruptcy law is far more complex than just “chasing debtors to the courthouse.” Still, the point is that within the past decade, many law firms like Cravath did not offer bankruptcy services to their clients. (There are lots of client-conflict issues, among other reasons.) Top-line firms likely would have referred the bankruptcy work out to other firms.

But things change. Bankruptcy has become a serious, and certainly respectable, form of law practice now, and can be a large moneymaking part of a major law firm. For large-scope bankruptcy cases, billing rates at some law firms are in the realm of $750 (and more) per hour of attorney time. Yes, that is quite pricey. And the bankruptcy judges seem to approve the fees, too. So let’s put 2 and 2 together. Large mainline, white-shoe law firms are building up their bankruptcy practices because they expect a lot of that kind of “debtor-chasing” business to come through the doors in the near future and pay out big fees. And what else does the future hold?

Loaded up With Debt

First, let’s catch up to the present. During the past few years, there has been a major change in corporate reorganizations. Prompted by the availability of easy -- if not cheap -- credit, many companies have loaded themselves up with debt. The debt was used for everything from making acquisitions and alliances to paying bonuses to managers to buying back stock options and outstanding shares. (On rare occasions, U.S. firms even use the borrowed money to build a new plant or factory, or to buy new equipment. Really, it has been known to happen.) At many business schools, they refer to this process of financial decapitalization as “the discipline of debt.” (And no, we won’t go there just now.)

Much of this new debt was then repackaged by the loan underwriters into other forms of financial instruments and flipped, sold and resold down the line to a myriad of buyers who may or may not have understood the nature of the risks they were assuming. There are few ironclad guarantees in this world, but I can almost surely guarantee you that when the loans go bad and the time comes to litigate over who is not getting repaid, the jilted creditors will deny up and down at depositions that they understood the nature of the risks. The creditors will claim, with straight faces, that they were lied to, misled, defrauded. Don’t believe me? Want to bet?

Enter the God of Insolvency

As with many things in life, it is nice when all goes well. But then again, things do not always go well. So when the god of insolvency enters upon the stage and drops his thunderbolts upon these deeply indebted firms and they “breach a material covenant,” as the saying goes, they often wind up attempting a financial workout or visiting the clerk’s office of a U.S. bankruptcy court to file their petition and the utterly critical first day motions. And just so you know, filing for bankruptcy is not something that you do when you have “no money.” It actually requires quite a bit of money for a business corporation to operate successfully in bankruptcy. Thus, strange as it seems, it helps to file for bankruptcy with money in the bank and receivables coming in (called “cash collateral”), or at least some sort of backup lender who is bold enough and willing to fund your operations after the bankruptcy petition is filed.

Welcome to the Future

So welcome to the future, where the smartest of the smart law firm money is betting that many more business firms will be visiting the bankruptcy courts of the land. This is why the big law firms are beefing up their bankruptcy rosters. This is part of the takeaway point for this week’s update. But how do these law firms think that they will get paid?

In many ways, hedge funds and private equity firms have turned the corporate bankruptcy process into another form of return-driven market. Among other things, these cash-rich entities have come to view the bankruptcy process as a marketplace for assets they can purchase at distressed prices, although many of the higher-quality assets have tended to command premium prices in bankruptcy sales of recent vintage. For this reason alone (and there are others), the presence of hedge funds and private equity firms has significantly transformed the process of bankruptcy. They have brought new money to the table, and deep pockets.

But in a world where you have debtors in possession of bankrupt corporations, and creditors getting stiffed up and down the line, and lawyers and related professionals charging large fees, and deep-pocketed buyers waiting at the fringes to buy assets or participate in recovery plans, you will have many new and previously unexplored legal issues. Professor Douglas Baird of the University of Chicago Law School recently noted that “We are about to go into a period of bankruptcy history where there are going to be lots and lots and lots of really unclear issues.”

Go to the Demographic and Economic Trends category on this site for more posts on this important topic.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Bankruptcy - The New Blue Chip Practice Area?:


Richard Maseles

Hi Susan. First, a small correction-- I am only an associate general counsel for MDOR. My boss, Omar Davis, is the general counsel.

But that's not the real reason I'm writing. I wanted to make an additional suggestion for a practice area for an enterprising solo-- creditor work for small businesses and local financial institutions. Since my last visit here, I've had talks with two senior officers of local banks, both of whom expressed dissatisfaction with the service they were receiving from their current law firms doing their bankruptcy work. Also, I've met several owners of small businesses who didn't realize their options when their customer/debtors filed bankruptcy. A good creditors' lawyer can advise these businesses and institutions on their options and pursue them vigorously. S/he also performs an equally vital function-- ensuring that the business not violate bankruptcy law, particularly the automatic stay provisions. Otherwise, Chuck Newton'll get 'em.

Being a good creditor's bankruptcy lawyer fits into the larger role of being a good creditor's lawyer generally-- and THAT is the field I would get into if I were starting a solo practice now. I like creditor work, and no, I don't believe you have to be a jerk to be good at it. Quite the contrary-- as in many aspects of life, I find more success using honey than vinegar, although I keep all the various kinds of vinegar close at hand if I need one of them.

The comments to this entry are closed.